A grisly looking, bulked up Joaquin Phoenix dominates nearly every frame of this memorably grim, violent and powerful film, and with little dialogue it is intensely cinematic and immersive. It puts one on edge without trying, not to mention dark: both figuratively and literally: the events of the film are not for the light of heart, and nearly every outdoor scene is shot at night.

Joe (Phoenix) plays a man who scares his neighbours, prompting them to go inside their house whenever he is around. Perhaps due to his unkempt beard and long, greasy hair, or maybe something more. He is a big, intimidating looking man but how much do these neighbours know about him? The opening scene alone raises questions as to both his mental state and what he is doing for a living.

The first we see of him is his face with a plastic bag over it, as if he is trying to kill himself. Trying to experience a journey towards death but not quite getting there. Is he suicidal? Maybe, but more probable is that it is has become a coping mechanism-turned-habit due to a troubled childhood. The horrors of war also haunt him; he is also in mourning or still troubled by the loss of a loved one; before tearing the plastic bag off his face a girl’s voice whispers to him, and once he has ripped the bag off he immediately burns a photo of a young girl. Within one scene we see an mentally broken, beaten down man. Needless to say, it is a powerful introduction.

His neighbours also may be avoiding him knowing of his job, though its exact nature is a mystery: after he tears the bag off, throwing it down the toilet filled with blood, he picks up all of what look like a girl’s belongings – including a bracelet with a name on it – and carefully leaves what looks like a hotel. Whatever he is doing, it doesn’t look legal. It already feels as if Lynne Ramsay is deliberately playing with the viewer, creating doubt not just with the opening scenes, but also with the title of film itself; whether it references the character of Joe or the memories that make him the man we witness, we never find out.

Revealing more of his character, apart from being a violent man (yet also caring as he looks over his grandmother) are flashbacks that pepper the film but never reveal much or last longer than a second, showing just enough to amplify the intensity of scenes without going into detail, not just maintaining atmosphere created but adding to it. The lack of detail may leave some wanting more, but what is seen effectively paints the type of person he has become, not to mention a couple of potential reasons for the large scar that dominates his upper back.

Due to these short and for the most part uninformative flashbacks, the violent events unfold unimpeded, with only quick flashes of his childhood, which add to the chilling vibe of certain scenes. Ramsey again uses misdirection, as well as a story that includes Joe’s hammer, as it is said at one point when he is hired, ‘I’ve heard that you can be brutal’ From here, we find out just how brutal.

Such a word almost isn’t enough to describe this man. Phoenix’s powerful performance and Jonny Greenwood’s score, alternating between hard electronic beats and strings where appropriate add yet more to black fog that hangs over this film, the very small use of dialogue more-so. And with everything unfolding at night, it feels appropriate for a movie this gritty. It constantly keeps the viewer guessing, but every other element used tells us what we need to know. Except for that damned title!

Coming out of nowhere for this viewer, Ramsey is not a director I was familiar with. But it is a film I have revisited several times, never quite knowing what to say. I look forward to going back through her films as well as waiting for her next.

Easily a full sixer. The best film of the year.


7 Comments on “YOU WERE NEVER REALLY HERE [2018]

  1. Nice review Jordan. I really enjoyed this as well (it made my honorable mentions of my 2018 list). I haven’t seen any of Lynne Ramsay’s other movies either, but this was very well-directed, plus I echo your thoughts on Phoenix’s performance and Greenwood’s score.

    My only complaint is the revelation that the governor was the one orchestrating everything, which to me felt very contrived. But considering that the film primary rests on Joe’s crippling depression, it didn’t take away much from the picture.

    Liked by 1 person

    • yeah I agree with you on that, but it seemed so outside what the film focuses on, I didn’t really notice. Phoenix is a beast in this, fuck he is so good!!!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s really good, right? I’ve seen it twice now and both times I was mesmerized by it. Ramsay has a real knack for mood and for visual storytelling. I thought her direction was superb.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hell yeah!! I’ve seen it 4 times now, there are so many ways you could interpret it. Even the title throws up questions…

      What other film of hers should I check out?


  3. Great post 🙂 I agree with everything you said here and Joaquin Phoenix is just amazing. I have seen all of Lynne Ramsay’s four films (this one included) and loved them all. This one is her masterpiece that tops all of her other masterpieces so far. Anyway, keep up the great work as always 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: THE BEST AND THE REST OF 2018 | the epileptic moondancer

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


seeker of wisdom

imperfection is perfection

Sporadic film reviews by a wanna-be filmmaker

ZeroTolerance to Negative Vibes

Barber life, struggle, life


renewed compassion

The No Spoiler Critic

Reviews, predictions & rants from the mind of Jason Singer with no plot points given away...ever.

The Cinematic Explorer

The good, the bad and the ugly; an uncensored look at the latest films hitting the big screen.


". . . first hand coverage, second hand news"

hands in the garden

reflection + romance + release

Rhyme and Reason

Poetry Meets Film Reviews

My thoughts on films, music, books, travel

No Nonsense with Nuwan Sen

Art Cinema & Literature site NS


Ramblings of the Cinema

Apparently I'm Bipolar

And I thought I just had a crazy personality!

Ranjith's shortreads

Wanderers in the world

Alif Satria

Humanity, Positive, Gratitude

Luke Atkins

Film, Music, and Television Critic

Alina Happy Hansen

Writer in San Francisco, CA

KG's Movie Rants

Movie reviews and occasional rants

%d bloggers like this: