imperfection is perfection
Sporadic film reviews by a wanna-be filmmaker
AFF: SHERPA [2015]
Running from October 15-25, the Adelaide Film Festival continues to run on full steam, while the program and tickets can be purchased here
Directed and Written by Jennifer Peedom
Mount Everest brings to mind many things. High altitudes, freezing temperatures and an increasing number of foreigners climbing the peak, at one point resulting in a traffic jam of epic proportions. It has become a business, with the Sherpa people always in the background; rarely expressing any emotion, helping out willingly as it is often the only way that these people can earn themselves a living – risking their lives time and time again to help complete strangers.
This film is told almost entirely from the perspective of the Sherpa. As we watch we see the insane risks that these people put themselves through, we also learn about the Sherpa as a native people. Deeply religious, they pray constantly that their journey will be successful and without death.
Their prayers are of course no guarantee, and in 2013 an almost inconceivable incident happened at 21,000 feet: a fight broke out between the Sherpa and the climbers they had been helping. They felt disrespected by a western climber who had referred to one of them as a mother f***er, which is pretty much the worst thing you could say to one of these people.
The small bits of footage captured from this incident show the usually calm and reserved Sherpa visibly angry. Tempers flared, rocks were thrown, as the Sherpa people finally let their voices be heard, knowing that foreign climbers see them almost as tools to help them achieve their goal, and don’t respect them and their work as a result.
That fight was the inspiration behind this Australian-made documentary as the filmmakers decided that to find out what had caused this tension, they should follow the Sherpa, interviewing them and their families, who often have a good sense of humour about a very dangerous job that their loved one is involved in. Also interviewed and extensively on camera is Russell Brice, who is one of many crew-leaders ready to lead his team to the summit. While he continues to fight for safer conditions on the mountain to this day, during the film he comes off as a bit of an insensitive douche; disrespecting the Sherpa and spreading rumours about them, while remaining blissfully ignorant of their hard work. His lack of respect is alarming given how much the Sherpa contribute to every climb.
This latter sentiment is unfortunate, given the work these people do. One of their tasks is to transport all that is needed – for the foreign climbers – up the mountain to each base camp.
The most brutal part of the Sherpa’s journey is that of the ice wall, literally a strip of ice that can move at any second. It must be traversed at night where there is a smaller chance of the ice shifting. Giant blocks of ice threaten their journey, yet the Sherpa continue without fear. Somehow this bravery is largely ignored by many foreign climbers who see the mountain as a tourist hot-spot; the more people climbing, the better for business. We even see flat-screen televisions at base camp. The rise of interest in the mountain is also raising the risk exponentially as the Sherpa are forced to climb the mountain several times a year, some up to thirty times.
This film is the anti-Everest. Looking even more stunning than that film, Sherpa charts the journey of the native Nepalese Phurba Tashin in the 2014 climbing season. What follows is a tragedy that leads to the Sherpa as a group making a list of demands, the meat of which involved compensation for unfortunate families left behind, as well as a rise in payment. For years the Sherpa have been silent, but here they become very vocal, accusing the government of taking their money; which is true in a sense, as they are paid pennies compared to what the business of climbing earns, parts of which go to the government. Their arguments were fair, but the reactions from some of the foreign climbers involved was disgusting to say the least, and shows just how little respect some of these foreign climbers have for the Sherpa despite the incredible work that they do, all of it so they can feed their family, and all of it to help the foreigners.
One American man actually referred to them as terrorists, simply because they were chanting for a rise in pay (in another language), while the circumstances meant that he couldn’t climb the mountain when he felt like it. As the protests continue, he actually asks his team leader if they can call the ‘owners’ of the Sherpa to sort out the situation. The packed IMAX cinema all chuckled in unison at his senseless, egregiously ignorant remarks.
One of the best films to come out of Australia, if not our best documentary ever, SHERPA is an intoxicating film
, showing real peril and tragedy from the mountain itself. Using a combination of draw dropping visuals, head-cam footage from the Sherpa climbers themselves, brief interjections of archival footage and talking heads from both the Sherpa and the foreign climbers, this flick paints the definitive film of Mount Everest, or as the locals call it, Chomolungma.
One beer short of a six-pack
5/6
14 Comments on “AFF: SHERPA [2015]”
Leave a Reply
CONTRIBUTIONS TO CINEMAAXIS
LAMB #1758
Blogs I Follow
imperfection is perfection 
I don’t know if I can handle much more Everest!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Heh, well it’ll take its time to make it to your neck of the woods cos its Aussie. But totally worth it and it shits all over Everest
LikeLike
Very keen to see this, the recent tragedy was so sad. I enjoyed Everest – it is what it is, etc etc! – but the lack of attention given to the Sherpas was disappointing (I think three died that day in the mid-90s but the film only pays them lip service). Still, it sounds like Sherpa addresses that imbalance, even if it will not be seen by anything like the same number of people. I’ll look out for it when it’s released here…the trailer looks very good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was a tragedy but hopefully it leads to better conditions for the Sherpa. It is sad though, as you’re right, nowhere near as many people will see this as Everest, which left me so flat i wrote nothing about it
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds really tense, great review bud.
LikeLike
Glad to see you’re enjoying AFF as I’m covering TCFF 😀 Very cool to see a similar subject of Everest climbing but from the perspective of the Sherpa, that makes it unique and more intriguing to me. I have to check this out!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s definitely worth a watch, they are interesting people
LikeLike
Hey did you see my tweet to you? I feel the same way about Anomalisa, as you did w/ The Martian 😉
LikeLike
just read it and your review. Sounds like an odd little film
LikeLike
Once again, another attention grabbing piece buddy. I would love to see this as the perspectives of Sherpas is not only underrepresented in reality but in the movies as well. Good for these guys for putting this together. Doesn’t sound like an easy watch, either, which is how it should be.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Its a heavy watch for sure, a lot of drama unfolded that the doco crew wasn’t expecting. We also got to hear thoughts from the producer, the director was going to be at the screening but was off out of the country accepting a prize! Catch this when you can, the Sherpa are interesting people
LikeLiked by 1 person
This one sounds right up my street Jordan. I’m definitely going to keep a look out for it here in the UK. I’m fascinated by Everest and its commercialisation and this sounds like it offers a refreshing take on the issues. Excellent review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is a refreshing take, you really get a sense of how…. ‘westernised’ the whole thing has become, and how the Sherpa are just taken for granted.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: MY TOP 20 FILMS OF 2015 | epileptic moondancer