I came into this movie knowing very little. I read one short review over at Natalie’s great blog, and that was all. Additionally, I am unfamiliar with the novels about the great character, hell I haven’t even seen the recent Guy Ritchie films about the man in his prime. But I like going into movies blind, I rarely watch trailers, and in this case I was going in even more ignorant to what I was about to see than usual. All I knew is that I am a fan of both Ian McKellen and Laura Linney.
So did my almost total ignorance effect my enjoyment of the film? Quite the opposite, which is why I always like going into films without knowing much about them. It always plays into my favour.
This is a subtle yet well paced drama that is driven mostly by its dialogue, where we meet Mr Holmes at 93 years of age. His memory is failing him and dementia is beginning to rear its ugly head as he lives with housekeeper Mrs. Munro (Laura Linney) and her son Roger (Milo Parker) – who shares incredible on-screen chemistry with McKellen. The two characters form a unique bond and it is great to watch. This is obviously not a comedy, but there is a lot of witty dialogue here that had me chuckling more than once, and overall the script is airtight. The cinematography and recognition of periods are gorgeous, really pulling the viewer into the film.
The film is essentially separated into two halves: one where Holmes’ age has rendered him a frail old man, both physically and mentally, while the other half concerns the last case Holmes ever took on. But his mind isn’t as sharp as it was, and he struggles mightily to remember this case, causing the extended flashbacks to be at times fractured. Despite this though, the film is never confusing. Holmes is trying desperately to remember and chronicle his last case, the one that caused him to turn his back on his profession, creating a character that is easy to care about.
I knew enough about the great detective to know that he had a partner, Watson, in his escapades, but during this film we only see Watson once, and it is during one of the extended flashbacks that make up his final case. Tellingly, we don’t see his face, nailing home the fact that they are no longer working together, or even in contact with each other. During the scenes that aren’t flashbacks, we also see Holmes’ annoyance with Watson’s exaggerated writing about him, perpetuating a myth that is no longer true and hasn’t been for some time.
His final case isn’t a riveting one, but it is intriguing and thought-provoking. The way the younger Holmes handles it, as well as the scenes of Holmes as an older man, provide an intimate character study of perhaps the most written about fictional character to have existed. The prosthetic work here is impeccable, as you can really tell the difference between the older Holmes and his younger self. As the movie moves on we gradually learn why he quit his profession, but at no time is it predictable. There are no clues for us to know why he stopped doing what he loved so much, creating some legitimate moments of tension throughout. His health at 93 also put me on the edge of my seat, though this of course is no thriller. It does however keep you guessing.
Mr Holmes is extremely well written and well acted, with a special mention to Milo Parker as the young son of Holmes’ housekeeper, Roger. A tight, character-driven film that doesn’t over-stay its welcome, I’d highly recommend this to fans of mystery-dramas and of course any fans of Sherlock Holmes. If you have a short attention span though, give this one a skip!
imperfection is perfection
Barber life, struggle, life
Reviews, predictions & rants from the mind of Jason Singer with no plot points given away...ever.
The good, the bad and the ugly; an uncensored look at the latest films hitting the big screen.
". . . first hand coverage, second hand news"
Poetry Meets Film Reviews
My thoughts on films, music, books, travel
Art Cinema & Literature site NS
The Casual Way to Discuss Movies
And I thought I just had a crazy personality!
Wanderers in the world
Humanity, Positive, Gratitude
Film, Television, and Music Critic
Movie reviews and occasional rants